9 Comments

When listening to your discussions about Illich, it struck me why I became enthralled with Pier Paolo Pasolini's life (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pier_Paolo_Pasolini). Their views on education and language were similar but distinct. Pasolini was equally as heretical but did not have the same support structure as Illich and met a fateful death at an early age.

Expand full comment

Pasolini sounds very interesting—thanks for bringing him up!

Expand full comment

He claimed that consumerism was worse than fascism. In fascism, you could escape within your private sphere, whereas in consumerism, there was no place to hide. His claim about schooling was that this is where you learn what your class was in society, as it is clearly on display from day one. I think you would like his view on the standardization of Italian and how it ruined cultures.

Expand full comment

This seems to be the crux of it: "our neoliberal culture lacks even a vocabulary of care—a sign of the degree to which we now live in a shared condition of carelessness."

Unfortunately, in our neoliberal culture, we only come to long for and appreciate care when we ourselves or someone close to us deeply needs it. Thanks, Elias, for helping to bring the word "care" forward in our vocabulary and, ultimately, our practice.

Expand full comment

Arendt is truly important, as you point out, not only in terms of what she articulates but the method, the sheer thinking process a reader can witness while reading her.

The passage on loneliness made me think of another idea, solitude, that comes up in Origins and also in Life of the Mind (1977). In the latter, emphasis is on thinking intentionally, in dialogues with oneself. She describes a Socratic 'two-in-one' (p. 187) that 'heals the solitariness of thought, in its inherent duality points to the infinite plurality which is the law of the earth'.

There is a kind of generative harmony being hinted at here, 'The partner who comes to life when you are alert and alone is the only one from whom you can never get away - except by ceasing to think' (p. 188). 'The self, too, is a kind of friend' (p. 189).

It is this sense of friendship I wish to cultivate in this new year. Thank you for writing this piece. Looking forward to more.

Expand full comment

Anshul, thanks for alerting me to this passage--wonderful. I hope you'll feel free to offer additional thoughts here!

Expand full comment

"Don't mourn, organize" (Mother Jones)

Expand full comment

👍 That’s where I’m going with this!

Expand full comment

right on

Expand full comment